Ooey gooey…chocolate dripping…sticky fingers. Ohhhhhh, it’s Valentine’s Day again. Valentine’s Day is a fun time for students to exchange gifts, show appreciation for their friends, and participate in classroom activities. However, with food allergies, sugar overload concerns (If you teach elementary or middle school, you understand.), and school policies limiting candy, non-candy Valentine’s Day gifts are a great alternative. Below are creative, thoughtful, and budget-friendly non-candy Valentine’s Day gift ideas for students.
Why Choose Non-Candy Gifts?
Non-candy gifts are ideal for classrooms because they:
- Avoid allergy risks associated with nuts, dairy, and gluten.
- Promote inclusivity, as some students may have dietary restrictions.
- Encourage creativity and long-lasting enjoyment.
- Support learning and engagement beyond the holiday.
- Reduce sugar intake while still making Valentine’s Day special.
Fun and Affordable Non-Candy Valentine’s Day Gift Ideas
School Supplies with a Valentine’s Twist
- Heart-Shaped Erasers – These small, colorful erasers are useful and fun for students.
- Pencil Toppers – Heart or Valentine-themed pencil toppers make great keepsakes.
- Valentine’s Day Pencils – Give students festive pencils with hearts, cupids, or messages.
- Mini Notebooks – Encourage students to jot down their thoughts with mini notebooks featuring Valentine’s Day designs.
- Crayon Packs – Small packs of crayons paired with a Valentine’s Day coloring sheet make a creative gift.
- Highlighters or Markers – Brightly colored highlighters or scented markers are practical and fun.
- Sticky Notes – Heart-shaped sticky notes can brighten any student’s day.
- Bookmarks – Create DIY bookmarks with inspirational Valentine’s quotes or fun designs.
Toys and Trinkets
- Mini Puzzle Games – Small Valentine’s-themed puzzle toys help develop problem-solving skills.
- Stickers – Valentine’s stickers are fun for decorating notebooks, folders, or water bottles.
- Glow Sticks – Give students a “glowing” reminder of how special they are.
- Bouncy Balls – Heart-shaped or red bouncy balls provide entertainment.
- Mini Stamps – Valentine-themed stampers are great for arts and crafts.
- Finger Puppets – Cute and engaging finger puppets make imaginative play even more fun.
- Slap Bracelets – These nostalgic bracelets come in Valentine’s prints and are loved by kids.
- Mini Fidget Toys – Fidget spinners, pop-it keychains, or squishy toys make great sensory-friendly gifts.
Crafty and DIY Gifts
Enter one of the most fun things for our students to do during the holiday season…making crafts. And, no, you don’t have to be an elementary school teacher to appreciate crafts.
- Friendship Bracelets – Make simple braided bracelets in Valentine’s colors. And, allow your students to share these with their friends if they like.
- DIY Valentine’s Cards – Handmade cards with positive messages add a personal touch. Once they are created, these keepsakes can be given to their favorite friends.
- Coloring Sheets – Print Valentine’s-themed coloring pages and pair them with a small pack of crayons. Okay, so this is more of an elementary school thing. But, even middle school students sometimes need a break. Plus, you can make these coloring sheets into an academic activity. Add some math. Create some writing prompts. Whatever it takes to make these personal.
- Beaded Keychains – Have students create their own Valentine’s keychain as a keepsake. (I happen to love these.)
- Paper Fortune Tellers – Create fun Valentine’s Day fortune tellers with sweet messages inside.
- Origami Hearts – Fold paper hearts and write a special note on them.
- Scratch-Off Messages – DIY scratch-off Valentine’s cards with hidden messages underneath.
- Decorate-Your-Own Mask or Crown – Give students a blank paper mask or crown to decorate with stickers and markers. And, allow them to wear these during class. This will help to create a fun, festive mood this Valentine’s Day especially for your elementary students.
Practical and Educational Gifts
- Mini Storybooks – Small books with Valentine’s themes encourage reading. (My fav! Hey, I’m a reading/English teacher. So, what did you expect.)
- Personalized Name Tags – Fun, decorated name tags for desks or lockers.
- DIY Science Experiment Kit – Create small experiment kits with simple supplies and instructions.
- Glow-in-the-Dark Stars – Encourage kids to dream big with glow-in-the-dark star stickers.
- Math Puzzle Cards – A fun and engaging way to practice math skills.
- Word Search or Crossword Puzzles – Valentine’s-themed activity sheets keep students engaged.
- Magnetic Bookmarks – Perfect for students who love to read.
- Reusable Water Bottles – Small bottles with Valentine’s stickers or student names on them.
Personalized Gifts
- Customized Pencils – Have student names or fun Valentine’s messages printed on pencils.
- Personalized Notes – Write a thoughtful note or positive affirmation for each student.
- DIY Photo Frames – Small frames decorated with Valentine’s designs.
- Handwritten Compliment Cards – Write one special thing about each student.
- Engraved Keychains – Simple keychains with initials or uplifting words.
- Custom Stickers – Design stickers with each student’s name.
- Friendship Certificates – Print personalized certificates celebrating student friendships.
- DIY Handprint Cards – Have students create a handprint card to remember their classmates.
Experiential and Activity-Based Gifts
- Valentine’s Bingo – Provide small bingo cards and let students play a fun game. (Bingo…Bango…, Sorry, I couldn’t resist)
- Treasure Hunt Clues – Create a classroom Valentine’s Day treasure hunt.
- Game Coupons – Hand out coupons that allow students to choose a fun classroom game.
- Reading Time Tickets – Give students a ticket for extra reading time with a special book. *** Not all students will like this one. So, be sure to only give these to your bookworms or book snobs.
- Homework Passes – A favorite among students, allowing a free pass on an assignment.
- Lunch Buddy Passes – Let students sit with a friend of their choice during lunch.
- Art Day Passes – Allow students to spend extra time on a creative project.
Tips for Distributing Non-Candy Valentine’s Day Gifts
- Make It Special – Present gifts in a decorated Valentine’s Day bag or envelope.
- Personalize the Experience – Write each student’s name on their gift for a personal touch.
- Pair with a Handwritten Note – Even a short note can make a gift feel more meaningful.
- Organize a Gift Exchange – Encourage students to bring non-candy gifts to share.
- Incorporate a Classroom Activity – Plan a Valentine’s Day craft or game to enhance the celebration.
Non-candy Valentine’s Day gifts are an excellent way to celebrate in a fun, inclusive, and creative manner. Whether you choose practical school supplies, small toys, DIY crafts, or experience-based gifts, these ideas ensure every student feels special and included. By focusing on thoughtful alternatives to candy, you create a memorable and enjoyable Valentine’s Day for all. And, best of all, you get to avoid the sugar rush and the extra clean up from candy.
Happy Valentine’s Day & Happy Teaching!!!
And, if you want to do a grammar review for your students this Valentine’s Day, then don’t forget to check out my resource on Teachers pay Teachers.
https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Product/Punctuation-Review-Valentines-Day-Themed-2927832
Other Articles to Read: